Is Sun Tea Dangerous?
Friday June 29, 2007
Sun tea is a popular and frugal drink, but is it a safe one? Not according to Snopes.com and more notably the Centers for Disease Control, which have both published information about the potential for sun tea to harbor dangerous bacteria. To find out more about what could be lurking in your tea check out:
Need a Substitute for Your Beloved Sun Tea?
Then, try refrigerator tea. It'll give you the same flavor you're used to, but none of the bacteria concerns. Ahh . . . now that's refreshing!
Comments
I have been making sun tea in a 1 gallon glass jar for over 15 years and haven’t died yet. What a bunch of hogwash.
You obviously haven’t been killed in a hit-and-run, either. Would you deny they happen to others? It’s not like it’s a major inconvenience to use your refrigerator instead of your back porch for tea-brewing. Considering that bacteria are becoming more and more difficult to fight with antibiotics, and all. (Germs kill more people than hit-and-runs do.) Sometimes I don’t know why scientists bother teaching the rest of us about stuff they find out, but if you’re that determined to blow off this particular finding, I guess it’s Darwin in action. *shrug*
here’s the thing, everybody:
i’d rather die from sun tea than be afraid of sun tea.
now that we have officially scared ourselves of everything – (i mean, what’s left? popping the heads off dandilions? hopscotch? key lime pie??) – let’s take a minute to remember one simple fact:
we are indeed going to die.
all of us.
you too.
maybe even today.
so it’s not the inconvenience or the sentimentality of the sun tea. it’s just: sun tea. and i refuse to be afraid of it, or of the bacteria it may harbor.
the reason germs are more difficult to fight with antibiotics is because we take too many antibiotics. let the body work a little, learn to withstand some germs, develop a healthy immune system. harder to do now that there is antibacterial spray, soap, air freshner, etc etc etc, but geez.
and let’s say you do it, you go on ahead and drink sun tea anyway, (damn the torpedoes! full speed ahead!!) and the unthinkable happens: you DIE from sun tea. well, so be it. we’re going to die from something. please god let me be so lucky as to die from sun tea.
we are spending our whole lives trying to stay alive instead of living. life is dangerous! life is uncertain! life can be scary, yes! but we have it so good here that we forget that it’s going to end someday relatively soon for each of us alive right now. and i am assuming this applies to you, too: if you have a computer and are capable of reading this, take a moment to reflect on how extremely lucky you are in the spectrum of human experiences. you are not, most likely, in Darfur. you probably aren’t being shot at by gang members or insurgents. you most likely HAVE a refrigerator. take a moment to reflect on the fact that you, reader, are alive, and probably safe, and relatively comfortable, else you would scarcely be reading about the $%#& dangers of SUN TEA.
we think this is how it’s always going to be and get attached to life and comfort and come up with crazy ways to insure we get to keep it, to stay alive and comfortable as long as possible. we go to school and spend years “learning” things we may never need to know and that may not interest us, things which we promptly forget as soon as our “test” is over, to increase the likelyhood of getting a job that we most likely are not passionate about, would not be doing if not for the money, to buy things we may not need, to increase the chances that we will still be able to be comfortable in our old age, so that we don’t have to think about dying. and we defend with our lives sometimes our “right” to these things.
everyone! get up from your computers right now! go into the kitchen, grab some tea bags and a glass jar filled with nice cold water, and set it out on the front porch. i hereby declare it national sun tea day in america! take back your life by proudly showing you REFUSE to be afraid of sun tea. and while you’re at it, if you’re not doing something you love, i mean really love, every day: sit back with your deeee-licious glass of sun tea and ask yourself: what am i waiting for.
i say this with deepest love and respect, and wish you peace.
rock on, sun tea rebels.
Refrigerator tea is a safer alternative. So is cold-brewed coffee–you can find recipes on the internet (since the beans have been roasted, there’s not the danger of harboring bacteria acquired in the field). I’ve visited a tea plantation in China as well as public markets. The worry of e-coli contamination is not an abstract one. The tea grows close to the ground, and there’s nothing to prevent animals (or people) from , well, contaminating it. Not that it happens all the time, but if you wash your vegetables that come out of the ground, it’s the same principle. The tea is dried and, for oolong and black tea, fermented, but never washed until you put it in water.
The chances of my being run down by a drunk person are greater than dying from drinking sun tea. Do you drink? Do you drive? Why isn’t everybody up in arms about drunk drivers, people talking on their cell phones when driving and doing a lot of other things when driving. I’m 73 years old, yes I will die but I’d rather die from drinking sun tea than a drunk driver or someone driving who is under the influence of some other illegal drug.
Hooray! for Alice and your mom!!! Be a rebel and drink that sun tea. I’m barely 40 and we “lived” outside – in the dirt *gasp*- and even played in the sandbox (with no lid) and probably ate some of the sand, too. My mom told us what don’t kill you makes you stronger and I think that goes for tragedy, dirt, sun tea and a miriad of other things. I think everyone would be well served and more healthy if they went outside and got some bacteria on ‘em and in ‘em!
I love the altitudes of these folks. Rock on sun-tea drinkers!!!
Psst!!……. I’m gonna out and buy a gallon jug and make me …..
Recently I put a gallon jug of herbal sun tea out all day, brought it in to drink and it was already fermenting and tasted horrible – I had to toss the entire gallon jug. I’ve been making refrigerator tea for some time and it has a wonderfully clean taste, very refreshing. And it’s easy – just put it in the refrigerator overnight and you have tea ready to go. That’s my route. This just confirms it.
I was surprised that the refrigerator tea tasted just as good to me if not better than the sun tea. I will say I get sick of the media constantly trying to scare me to death with all the health scares. You either have good genes or you don’t, to my way of thinking. So much obsession with the body and physical health is just a waste of time.
How can they cook safely in solar ovens if tea in a jar is not to be used? Frugal
‘your mom’ and alice-i love both your comments! this reminds me of a recent rant i went on to a freind: several weeks back i went out to run some errands. beautiful midwest day,75 degrees,afternoon. i saw only 1 child outside. he was probably 9 or 10, fully loaded with helmet,knee pads, elbow pads,training wheels, and riding his bike up and down a 10 foot driveway,back and forth. and i saw not one other child out for the several hours i was out and about. i assume all the children were indoors because their parents are so afraid to let them play outside due to fear. i will sarcastically assume that this child of brave parents was probably wearing sunscreen and bugspray
Why would anyone want to drink something knowing that it can potentially make you sick? I don’t understand. Do you leave food out all day and still it?
I read the Snopes article (doesn’t About have an Urban Legends Guide?) and got a different take on it. Sun tea is perfectly safe if you’re sure to clean your container very well. It’s not the sun tea that is a problem, it’s the possibility of bacteria already in the container.
Also, ultraviolet light from the sun kills microbeasties. That’s a known fact.
A little logical thinking goes a long way.
Perhaps this “caution” may be from the same woman who sued McDonald’s for giving her hot coffee…
I guess I’m confused. Why is making refrigerated tea ok and sun tea not? I thought the whole idea was to reach a temperature of 195 to kill bacteria. That doesn’t happen in the fridge.
at refrigerator temperatures, most bacteria will either not grow at all or will grow very slowly.
U know, i’ve drank sun-tea my entire life, and just because people find bacteria in it, does not mean i’m going to stop drinking it. I’ve made refrigorator tea, boiled tea, instant tea. Theres something about letting the tea steap in the sun that gives it a distinct flavor. Maybe its the bacteria that taste good.
Anyhoo i have never been sick from sun tea, nor have i ever met anyone thats ever been sick from sun tea. Seems like were not suppose to do anything these days. In my opinion, its the ones who obsess over bacteria that makes them ill from it, MENTALLY ILL. Bacteria is all around us people, just keep your tea pitchers clean, and keep on brewing.
Cheers
I like the comment Chris made “Maybe its the bacteria that taste good”
Probably so…
Whether or not sun tea is good for you, it takes too long to make. Get a gallon jug and put into it about ten tea bags(experiment until you find the right amount of tea bags that work for you) and fill the jug with hot water from the faucet. In about half an hour shake up the jug, remove the tea bags, fill a glass with ice cubes and enjoy. Put the rest of the tea in the fridge. Lemon and sugar can be added to the jug or to the glass. Have it your way.
What a crock!!!!!!! Go ask Alice.
Agree with most comments on this subject. If Sun-tea is unsafe because the water hasn’t been boiled, then so is the water coming out of your tap – and no one is advocating boiling ALL the water we drink. Tap water is not cold enough to inhibit bacterial growth, nor hot enough to ‘kill ‘em where they strand’…
I think I’m more at risk from the deteriorating ozone layer than I am a jug of sun-tea. To me, this is a complete NON-issue.
Folks, the reason tea has caught on so well as a healthful beverage in Asia is that it is BOILED. People noticed that tea drinkers died less frequently than non-tea drinkers. They decided that tea was good for you.( most water throughout the world is dirty)
I’ve found that mixing a little grenadine and vodka in sun tea tends to kill a lot of the little critters….
Mr. Mohr,
Hot water from the Hot water heater is not for drinking. You have you ever flushed you water heater?
This is the biggest bunch of Bunk I have ever heard of .. I live in Arizona and we have made suntea for centuries! If I listen to all the negative reports that came out over the years – I be dead from starvation as well.. No wonder Americans are such a sick bunch – everything has to be germ free so their bodies have no defense in their system for bacteria .. A certain amount of bacteria is needed to be healthy.
#24 Karine wrote:
“This is the biggest bunch of Bunk I have ever heard of .”
I already discredit a comment when I read exaggerative comments like “the biggest bunch of Bunk.” Well, if this is the biggest then you clearly don’t search the web or read much.
As a medical researcher and health advocate, I’m always amazed by ignorance out there — especially from people clearly ill-informed about health and medicine. Karine’s comment is typical.
First, let’s look at her “logic.” She wrote:
“I live in Arizona and we have made suntea for centuries!”
So what? You seriously need a basic class in Statistics or even Critical Thinking. How do you know that people haven’t gotten sick from it? Have you done epidemiological studies to see if there are correlations with gastrointestinal distress, cancers, immune disorders, etc? How do you know the long term effects? Cancers and ulcers, for example, happen far in the future.
Why are you so dismissive of medical experts? Based on what? On “centuries” of experience? Reliable epidemiological modeling wasn’t even a science until late last century. So was there a CDC in the 19th century? Just how was data for suntea collected? By word of mouth? Is that what you consider science? Is that what you want taught in medical school?
Here’s more evidence of Karine’s ignorance of the subject: “No wonder Americans are such a sick bunch – everything has to be germ free so their bodies have no defense in their system for bacteria .. A certain amount of bacteria is needed to be healthy.”
Er, get out a basic textbook on immunology. Germ free? Have you heard of e. Coli? How about Enterobacteriaceae, enterococci, bifidobacteria, and Bacteroides? Our healthy intestines are estimated to have about 100 TRILLION organisms, comprising of 300-1000 different species. Does that sound germ-free to you?
The existing flora in our guts live in balance with our body, with many actually helping its function. Why would you want to upset that balance and introduce a foreign organism, especially ones that the CDC deems harmful? Are you seriously claiming that it helps maintain a normal immune system? WRONG. Adult immune systems are generally not helped by DIETARY introduction of a pathogen. Yes, it may help to expose infants to environmental pathogens, but as adults, our immune systems are established and the introduction of pathogens may actually cause an allergic reaction and possibly even death from anaphylatic shock. Your logic simply doesn’t make sense. Even with children, oral introduction is NOT the way to go.
Karine, you may want to live in the 17th century but it is completely irresponsible to post such misinformation. I feel sorry for those around you, who give you credence. Seriously, go get a real medical textbook for information rather than The National Enquirer. Or just ask your physician.
I agree with Bryan. If you think it’s okay to leave tea basking in the sun for many hours, then you’re also okay with leaving food out unrefrigerated for long periods. The situation is exactly the same. Yet most people would prefer not to leave their food outside overnight.
Experts say that moisture-rich foods should never be left out for more than 2 hours, and that bacteria can double every 20 minutes.
Boiling the water only helps to a certain extent. Unless you adhere to the guidelines for canning, bacteria in the air immediately returns to the bottle. Again, let’s look at your dinner foods. Most were cooked above the temperature that would kill bacteria. Yet it still gets spoiled.
You guys who say that you don’t care about the risks are certainly welcomed to keep consuming it. After all, look how many people still smoke despite the known dangers. But don’t be arrogant and claim that the CDC is wrong (where is YOUR proof?). Acknowledge the facts and then admit that you don’t care. And just like smoking, don’t be irresponsible and subject your children to the risks.
Karine: your posts is incredibly ignorant and illogical. I only took a freshman courses in biology and critical thinking and even I know that your conclusions are wrong.
I just want to point out that being out in sunlight gives the perfect temperature to breed bacteria, approx 70-90 degrees. Furthermore, it’s usually humid (which doesn’t much matter since the tea itself is moisture). It is the EXACT OPPOSITE to the environment for fighting spoilage. A cool, dark, dry place. We’ve all heard that recommendation, and a fridge fits that perfectly. The outdoor sun environment is the opposite: It PROMOTES spoilage. Think about it.
What on earth is sun tea? I live in England and although tea is common place, sun is not so much, that may be why sun tea is not known here.Please enlighten me!
Malena (28) asked, “What on earth is sun tea?”
Simply put tea bags and cold water into a pitcher and put it in sunlight to brew. In several hours, you’ll have tea. Most recipes don’t even ask that the water be boiled or that the container be covered. That allows germs and insects into the tea and multiply in the warm sun.
The “recipe” was invented centuries ago before the use of electricity, refrigeration or even knowledge of germs (Pasteur, 19th century). That’s why it’s shocking to me that people would do it today, given modern sanitary methods of cooking. Worse, they refuse to believe the studies showing the risks. Notably, populations that make sun tea are generally more rural, older, poorer and less educated (note that I wrote “GENERALLY”).
I mean, would you leave raw fish out in the sun for several hours to cook?
I agree with Shawn that the people who defend Sun Tea, and especially those who brew it, are generally less educated. My grandparents and to a lesser extent my parents were among them. After college and just some basic biology, I swore off the stuff and my parents agreed. There is simply no reason for it. For examples of what I mean by less educated just look at the defenders on this board, i.e. the first message said that she’s been making sun tea for 15 years but hasn’t died yet. That’s the kind of backward hick logic I’m talking about.
Oh my god, I am amazed by the ignorance of some of these posts. Just look at the first message, from Alice. She wrote that she’s been making sun tea for 15 years but haven’t die yet so the medical report must be “hogwash.” Talk about arrogance and stupidity. Has she heard about cancer and heart disease? Many people smoke for 15 years before cancer is detected, and likewise for eating high fat. And many toxins collect in the body before effects are seen.
Then she wrote on July 4, 2007: “Why isn’t everybody up in arms about drunk drivers”
What is she talking about??? People aren’t up in arms about drunk drivers??? Er, there are laws about it! And people are sued and incarcerated. Do we do that over sun tea. get real, Alice.
FInally, she wrotes, “I’m 73 years old, yes I will die but I’d rather die from drinking sun tea than a drunk driver”
Again, absolutely no connection at all. Sun tea has nothing to do with drunk driving, so it’s not a matter of choosingone over the other. And Alice, you want to risk yourslf, go ahead. But don’t go around telling others that it’s not risky and dont expose others, especially children, to the risk. I bet you also smoke in front of babies because you don’t care about the risk.
Bryan – Somehow your expertise in clinical research left you oblivious to the fact that e.coli is not the bacteria at issue in regards to sun tea; it’s alcaligenes viscolactis. It’s a bacteria that is present in tap water and the worst it will do is cause diarrhea. When this bacteria is present in sun tea it makes the tea cloudy and ropey. Just as people would not drink chunky or filmy milk, they would not drink cloudy tea with tendrils floating in it.
Juliet, I’m laughing at your ridiculous interpretation of what Bryan said. I’m always appalled at this sort of stupidity. So many people assimilate what they read very poorly, or pay no attention what is actually being said. Bryan never said anywhere in his post that e. Coli (or any of the other types of bacteria he mentioned) has anything to do with sun tea. He was speaking about bacteria in general, in relation to another post that made inaccurate assertions. He was using those bacteria as examples in order to make a point. This should have been obvious to anyone with even a minimal amount of intelligence. You are the only one who is “oblivious”. Next time you decide that you want to come across as intelligent by trying to make someone else look stupid, you’d better think twice.
I ran across this article a few minutes ago while looking for creative iced tea recipes. It’s the first I’ve heard of it. In the past, I occasionally made sun tea, and can’t specifically recall being sick from it. However, in light of this information, I think it makes good sense to follow some precautions and make iced tea another way.
Why are so many of you talking about what will or can “kill” you? The point with the sun tea is not that you will die from it, but that it could potentially make you feel ill to varying degrees. Have you ever had indigestion or felt a bit queasy without knowing why? Quite often we ingest things that cause mild to moderate symptoms that we certainly do not “die” from, and it’s often difficult to pinpoint why, or to know what it was that made us feel that way. Mild illness is usually passed off without much concern. Sometimes we just figure it was a virus, or something that did not agree with us.
I can’t recall that I’ve ever felt sick from sun tea, but obviously there is a potential, and I’d rather not put myself in that situation. The rest of you can do whatever you choose. We are all free to make our own choices. I’m not looking to prevent myself from “dying”, but I personally do not like feeling ill.